Ok, so it’s never a surprise when I say I’ve stopped into a Sephora, in fact it’s starting to seem a little redundant as they are everywhere in the city. Speaking of which, they reaaaally need to get on down to Brooklyn somewhere, seriously these stores are popping up all over Manhattan some as close as five blocks away from each other! Although, I might end up with a REAL problem if they did put one in Brooklyn, you know like those people on that show, Hoarders. Only instead of being overrun with spoons and dead animals you’d have to dig through piles of mascara to find me.
So anyway, yes, I went into Sephora a bit ago and one of my gifts with purchase was a set of Fresh’s Sugar Lip Treatments. I went through those babies like water. I went back to get more and the price tag of those babies shocked the hell out of me! $22?! It’s a prettier version of CHAPSTICK! So after my WTF moment, I put them down and moved on, but I really wanted them and I knew even though I loved them there was no way I could justify the price unless there were no similar items on the market….!!!

After much testing I found there were MANY similar products on the market at a fraction of the price, BUT, there was nothing that offered the benefits of the lip balm and the color of a lipstick like the ones by Fresh. Until Revlon came out with those lip butters that is, when exactly did they come out with these? I have no idea, I had heard so many rave reviews of other bloggers gushing about how wonderful they are but had yet to actually SEE them anywhere. I finally caught them at a Rite Aid, while on sale no less! I grabbed the only one of the bunch that I thought would look good on me, a hot pink color called Sweet Tart. *These come in a TON of colors, but the ones the store had left were for lighter skin tones. These things are flying off the shelves!

Product VS Product:
Fresh Sugar Lip Treatment in Rose VS Revlon Lip Butter in Sweet Tart
Color: These are both 2 different shades of pink, but they are both that sort of pink that will look amazing on anyone. Both products offer a smooth lip balm feel that glides quite nicely over your lips and a beautiful sheer color that can easily be layered for more coverage. Fresh offers about 5 colors total and 2 colorless versions. Revlon has a huge range from nudes and pinks to purple, peach and red.
Packaging: Revlon offers a more traditional lipstick tube, with a really cute lid that matches the color inside and a clear top for easy viewing of the color. It’s sturdy and snaps securely. The Fresh packaging is downright innovative, offering a screw on top in what appears to be your typical chapstick tube. The darker shades tube match the colors inside but none of the others really do, the only downside to this is sometimes you will forget to screw it shut and the lid will come off, if it’s not in your purse it’s no big deal but these can get really messy if they are!
Price: $22 for Fresh, $7 for Revlon.
Overall: While both products are great I really have to say “Get the Revlon” because it comes in a ton of colors and you can get THREE for the price of one of the Fresh’s Sugar Lip Treatments!
Honorable Mentions: $3 for both
EOS lip balm – it comes in a cute little sphere tube! No colors, but they feel amazing and are great for days I don’t want to wear lipstick or gloss.
Nivea lip balms – These are usually called things like “Touch of: Honey, Softness, Smoothness, Color, etc” The color ones add a nice sheer wash of color but they don’t layer much, these offer sunscreen protection and really make your lips feel like silk.